Surgery · Technique Comparison

SMAS Facelift vs Deep Plane Facelift

Two planes of dissection, and the one Rewind publishes

Gangnam, Seoul | Board-certified plastic surgeon, Dr. Jonghwan Choi
Techniques compared, anatomy first · KHIDI-registered for overseas patients

SMAS vs Deep Plane SMAS vs Deep Plane SMAS vs Deep Plane SMAS vs Deep Plane 
Planes

The difference in one answer

What separates a SMAS facelift from a deep plane facelift?

The short answer

Both operate on the SMAS, the fibrous fascial layer under the skin and fat that carries the tension of the face. In a SMAS facelift the skin is lifted as one flap and the SMAS is handled as a second, separate layer that is tightened and fixed. In a deep plane facelift, as the technique is described in the surgical literature, the surgeon passes beneath the SMAS early and keeps skin and SMAS joined as one composite flap across the cheek, releasing the retaining ligaments from below so the whole unit moves together.

Rewind's published full lift sits between the two labels in one respect: its steps raise the skin first, then open the SMAS, release the retaining ligaments beneath it and raise the fascia as its own flap. The clinic describes this as a SMAS-layer operation and does not call it a deep plane facelift, so this page does not either.

The description of Rewind's operation is taken from the clinic's Korean surgical page for full facial lifting. Descriptions of the deep plane technique come from the papers listed at the foot of this page. How far beneath the SMAS the dissection extends for a given face is not published and is confirmed at consultation.

The debate between the two techniques is older than most of the patients reading about it. A 1990 paper introduced the deep-plane rhytidectomy as a way of moving the cheek with its skin still attached; SMAS techniques had been developed from the 1976 anatomical description of the layer itself. Surgeons have argued since about which lasts longer, which looks more natural and which carries more risk to the facial nerve.

For a patient the useful question is narrower: what will actually be done to my face, in which plane, and by whom. That question can be answered at an examination, and the sections below set out what to ask.

Dr. Jonghwan Choi operating with loupes and a headlight during facelift surgery
Fig. 01 · The plane is chosen in theatre, under magnification
Layers

The anatomy both techniques share

The four facial layers every SMAS or deep plane facelift must deal with

Both techniques pass through the same layers in the same order. They differ in where they separate one layer from the next, and in which layers they keep together.

layer 01
Skin and the fat under it
In a SMAS lift the skin is lifted off the layer beneath across a wide field. In a deep plane lift, beyond the point of entry, the skin is left attached to what lies under it.
layer 02
The SMAS
The superficial musculoaponeurotic system, first mapped in the cheek and parotid region in 1976. Both techniques tighten it; they differ in whether it travels alone or together with the skin.
layer 03
Retaining ligaments
Fibrous bands described in the cheek in 1989 that tether the soft tissue to deeper structures. Releasing them is what allows the tissue to be moved in a new direction.
layer 04
The plane beneath the SMAS
The space in which deep plane dissection is performed. Branches of the facial nerve run deeper still, and their position relative to this plane is why the anatomy matters.

Rewind's published steps pass through all four: the skin flap is lifted, the SMAS is opened, the ligaments beneath the SMAS are released, and the fascia is raised, drawn taut and fixed before surplus skin is removed.

Compare

Point by point

Five points where SMAS and deep plane facelifts part ways

Neither technique is a single fixed recipe; each surgeon adapts it. The points below describe the techniques as the literature presents them, and note where Rewind's published operation sits.

01Flap

One composite flap, or two separate layers

Deep plane: skin and SMAS move as one unit across the cheek. SMAS lift: the skin is raised on its own and the fascia is tightened as a second layer. Rewind publishes the two-layer sequence.

02Ligaments

How much is released, and from which side

Ligament release from beneath the SMAS is the centre of the deep plane description. Rewind also releases the retaining ligaments beneath the fascia before raising its SMAS flap, according to its own surgical steps.

03Entry

Where the SMAS is opened

A 2018 study of fourteen patients measured more vertical and horizontal tissue movement along the jaw line when the SMAS was entered higher on the face than at the standard point. Rewind does not publish its entry point.

04Nerve

How close the dissection runs to the facial nerve

Working beneath the SMAS brings the surgeon nearer to the motor branches of the facial nerve, whose depth is predictable in three dimensions. That is a reason for care in either technique.

05Outcome

What pooled studies report

A 2025 meta-analysis of 21 studies and 2,896 patients found satisfaction of 94.4 percent for deep plane and 87.8 percent for SMAS lifts, with overall complication rates of 17.2 and 10.3 percent. Both techniques were judged to give robust, long-term results.

Draped preparation of a facelift patient in the procedure room at Rewind
Fig. 02 · Preparation, before the first layer is opened
Rewind

How Rewind treats the label

Why Rewind describes its facelift by the layer it moves

Technique names travel faster than the details behind them. Two surgeons can use the same name for different dissections, and the same dissection can be sold under two names. Rewind publishes its steps and names the layer, and anything beyond those steps is discussed in person.

01Steps

The published sequence is the claim

Skin flap raised, SMAS opened, ligaments released beneath it, fascia fixed, surplus skin removed. Those are the steps Rewind stands behind, whatever label a reader brings to them.

02Face

The plane is chosen for the face in front of the surgeon

How heavy the cheek tissue is, how deep the folds run and how far the jaw line has dropped all affect how the dissection is planned. That judgement is made at examination and explained to you there.

03One author

The surgeon who plans the plane is the one who dissects it

Dr. Jonghwan Choi examines, operates and reviews every facelift at Rewind. No second operator is involved, so the plan described at consultation is the plan carried out.

Dr. Jonghwan Choi assessing a patient's jaw line before choosing a facelift plan
Fig. 03 · Tissue weight and descent are read by hand before any plane is chosen
Theatre

Where the choice is made

Where the facelift technique is decided, and who decides it

Operating room at Rewind Plastic Surgery, Apgujeong

Fig. 04 · The theatre in the Richro Building, Apgujeong

Consultation room at Rewind Plastic Surgery, Apgujeong

Fig. 05 · The consultation room, where the plane is explained

Two rooms matter for this decision. In the consultation room the surgeon examines how the face has descended and explains which layers he intends to move and why. In the operating room on the fourth and fifth floors of the Richro Building in Apgujeong, Gangnam, the same surgeon carries that plan out. Consultations are booked ahead, Monday to Wednesday and Friday until 19:00 and Saturday until 16:00.

Published technique: SMAS-layer facelift
Skin flap raised as its own layer
Retaining ligaments released beneath the SMAS
SMAS drawn taut and fixed
No deep plane description published
Operated by Dr. Jonghwan Choi
Dr. Jonghwan Choi, board-certified plastic surgeon

Board-certified plastic surgeon

Dr. Jonghwan Choi holds Korean specialist certification in Plastic Surgery and is the only operating surgeon at Rewind, so the technique discussed at consultation is never delegated. The clinic is KHIDI-registered for international patients, Reg. M-2025-01-08-09288.

Cost

Pricing

Does the facelift technique change the price at Rewind?

Rewind's fee sheet lists facelift operations by scope. There is no separate line for a deep plane facelift, because the clinic does not publish one; the plane used within a full lift is a surgical decision inside the listed operation.

Full facelift, SMAS layerComplete incision route, ligaments released beneath the fascia, SMAS fixed
₩9,000,000
Facelift combined with neck liftWhere the descent continues below the jaw line
₩14,000,000
Mini faceliftA shorter stretch of the incision, middle and lower face
₩3,000,000

Fees shown before VAT, anaesthetic fee counted in. Whichever facelift listing applies is written into your plan at consultation.

So the comparison on this page is a surgical one. Whether your plan reads ₩9,000,000 or ₩14,000,000 depends on how far the descent reaches, not on the name of a technique.

Fit

Fit

When the SMAS facelift fits, and when to ask about deeper release

A SMAS-layer lift is the usual answer when

  • Folds beside the nose, cheeks, jaw line and neck have descended together
  • Skin elasticity has fallen past the reach of thread and laser lifting
  • You want one operation with a large correction and a long recorded working life
  • You are ready for a week in a compression dressing and four weeks of restrictions

Ask the surgeon directly when

  • You have read about deep plane surgery and want to know how far beneath the SMAS your plan goes
  • Heavy cheek tissue or deep folds are your main concern, since these affect how the dissection is planned
  • You have had a facelift before, which changes the tissue planes the surgeon will find
  • You take blood thinners, smoke, have a clotting disorder or an infection near the incision line
After

Recovery

Recovery after Rewind's SMAS facelift, stage by stage

Recovery claims for one technique over the other are hard to compare across studies. What can be stated is what Rewind records for its own full lift, which is the operation you would be having here.

Week one
Compression
A compression dressing for about a week. The dissection is wide, so swelling and a tight, heavy feeling are expected early.
Early weeks
Settling
Pain and swelling improve gradually. Pressure on the face and strong massage of the operated area are avoided.
Four weeks
Activity
No strenuous exercise, sauna or steam rooms for at least four weeks. Alcohol and smoking are kept out of the same period.
Months
The scar
Sun protection and scar care, since the healing line along the hairline and ear can darken if exposed.

Either technique carries surgical risk: bleeding, haematoma, infection, prolonged swelling, asymmetry, numbness, facial nerve injury and scarring among them. Tell the surgeon about any earlier facial surgery and every medication before a date is agreed. Individual results vary.

Doctor

Professional

At Rewind, one board-certified plastic surgeon carries every case — from the first consultation to the final follow-up. Because a face is a story, and a story deserves a single author.

Dr. Jonghwan Choi, board-certified plastic surgeonRewind,
Dr. Jonghwan Choi presenting at an academic session
Fig. 06 — Academic presentation, thread-lifting session

Rewind's Doctor

Dr. Jonghwan Choi Medical Director

One surgeon, from the first
consultation to the last follow-up.

A board-certified plastic surgeon devoted to anti-aging lifting — with the precision and restraint built through years of craniofacial practice.

Board-certified plastic surgeon (Plastic Surgery)
10 peer-reviewed publications
Medical Director, Rewind Plastic Surgery
Korean Society of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgeons
Former chief director, Apgujeong Y&T Plastic Surgery
Korean Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery
J Craniofac Surg · JKMS · Arch Craniofac Surg
Korean Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Association
Voices

Google Reviews

What our patients say.

G 5.0 ★★★★★ 40 Google reviews · Rewind Plastic Surgery, Apgujeong — live-synced from Google Business Profile

"There are just way too many cosmetic clinics in Korea and I'm so happy I found Rewind Clinic in Gangnam. Dr. Choi was so kind and patient while explaining the different face-lifting options, from threads to mini-lifts to deep-plane lifts. I've had procedures in Taiwan and the US and now m…"

JJ. S.3 MONTHS AGO · POSTED ON GOOGLE

"Really nice environment. Doctor is easy to communicate and understands my visions. Waited two weeks to make a review and I confirm the results exceeded my expectations and I am super happy with it. Can't wait to come back!! :))"

KKristie Chu3 MONTHS AGO · POSTED ON GOOGLE

"I found Rewind clinic through a Korean chat forum and many local clients highly recommended it. The clinic is brand new, featuring large, clean rooms and many private waiting areas so it doesn't give off that "factory" clinic vibe. All the staff, including the receptionists, nurses, a…"

JJ. Siou3 MONTHS AGO · POSTED ON GOOGLE

"You know how you get self-conscious about your facial contours before going on vacation? I was wondering what I could do to see quick results, and a friend recommended Apgujeong Rewind Plastic Surgery. All the staff were friendly, and the facilities were incredibly pleasant—it felt like a hotel! Val…"

똑띠언니A MONTH AGO · POSTED ON GOOGLE · Translated by Google

"I went for a consultation for lip fillers and am leaving this review because I am so satisfied with the results. I told them about the lip line I had always wanted, and they carefully examined my face shape and features to naturally recreate a shape that suited me well. The director definitely has …"

WWang, Ziyuan(경영대학 경영학과) ­2 MONTHS AGO · POSTED ON GOOGLE · Translated by Google
Ask

Questions

SMAS vs deep plane facelift: what patients ask

How does a SMAS facelift differ from a deep plane facelift?
Both tighten the SMAS, the fascial layer beneath the skin. A SMAS facelift lifts skin and fascia as two separate layers. A deep plane facelift passes beneath the SMAS and moves skin and SMAS together as one flap, releasing the retaining ligaments from below.
Which technique suits Asian facial anatomy better?
No study settles that for every face. A 2017 paper described adapting an extended SMAS technique specifically for Asian patients. What matters for you is the weight of the cheek tissue, the depth of the folds and the descent of the jaw line, which Dr. Choi assesses at examination.
Which of the two does Rewind's published full lift match?
Rewind's steps raise the skin first, then open the SMAS, release the ligaments beneath it and fix the fascia as its own flap. That is a two-layer SMAS operation with ligament release, and the clinic does not label it deep plane. Any further extension is discussed in person.
Does a deep plane facelift last longer than a SMAS facelift?
The evidence does not show a clear winner. A 2025 meta-analysis concluded that both give robust, long-term results with high satisfaction. Rewind records more than ten years for its full SMAS lift, with variation between individuals, and ageing continues on top of any result.
Is one technique riskier for the facial nerve?
Dissection beneath the SMAS runs closer to the facial nerve branches, so anatomical care matters in either technique. The 2025 meta-analysis pooled overall complication rates of 17.2 percent for deep plane and 10.3 percent for SMAS lifts, from separate study groups and not a head-to-head trial.
Does the technique change the price at Rewind?
No. The fee sheet lists facelifts by scope: the full lift at ₩9,000,000, the lift combined with the neck, and the mini operation. There is no separate deep plane listing. The anaesthetic fee is included in each figure and VAT is added.
Do the two techniques leave different scars?
The scar follows the incision route more than the plane beneath it. Rewind's full lift runs from the temple hairline around the ear into the hairline behind it, where hair and the ear contour conceal it. It is still a surgical scar and needs sun protection while it matures.
Why do surgeons still disagree about which is better?
Studies measure different things, follow patients for different lengths of time and are rarely randomised. Satisfaction, complications and visible change are each reported in their own way. For that reason, the technique is more usefully judged against your own anatomy, which can only be done at examination.
Booking

Reservation

REWIND,booking

Tell us what you are considering — we reply within one business day, in your language.

Scientific evidence

Published research on SMAS and deep plane facelift technique

These papers describe the two techniques as a class: the anatomy of the SMAS and of the cheek ligaments, the original deep-plane description, a pooled comparison of outcomes, and a fascial technique adapted for Asian faces. They are cited to explain the comparison and do not describe the operation performed at Rewind or predict anyone's result.